Israel’s relationship with Russia is changing direction

Comments

1. 

   Banquo

   October 9, 2023

   Mark, it is right to be discussing the current war, but we should also be discussing the wider context and eventual resolution.

   In the short term, Israel should have every right to retaliate in self-defence, as any country under siege should. However, in the long term, it has to be acknowledged that Israel has contributed to the beginning of this war by driving so many desperate Gazans (Gaza is effectively an open-air prison in which everyone is poor and young people have no prospects) into the hands of Hamas.

   The long-term solution is two separate states existing side by side and respecting each other, as well as Israel treating its Arab citizens as fairly as it does its Jewish ones. Unfortunately, Israel is doing the exact opposite of this, occupying ever more land which is essential that Israel eventually gives up to Palestinians to win the peace.

   Meanwhile, Israel itself is becoming ever more chauvinistic, treating Arabs like dirt and promoting Jewish superiority over Islam (similar to what India is doing by constant extreme promotion of Hinduism and denigration of its Muslim minorities). The current government is an extreme right-wing one which wants to push divisive policies, crush the judiciary which usually acts as a check on the executive (thankfully, not without pushback from liberal-minded Israelis), and capture ever more Palestinian land. It is not an exaggeration to state that Israel is becoming an apartheid state.

   No wonder Arabs and Palestinians are angry.

   Palestinian politicians are of course not helping the situation. The good guys on the Palestinian front are supposed to be the Palestine Liberation Organisation and the political party Fatah, but the last time elections were held for positions in the Organisation was in 2005/2006. The leadership is weak and corrupt, and has achieved nothing tangible in terms of establishing a state for the Palestinians or gaining more rights for the people it supposedly represents.

   So, naturally, ordinary Palestinians prefer the Hamas militia to Fatah. At least, Hamas actually seems to be doing something to fight for Palestinian rights when it fires rockets into Israel, even if Gazans end up paying with their lives when Israel inevitably retaliates with its modern and powerful army.

   Over the decades, Arab states like Saudi Arabia have staunchly supported Palestine out of principle and solidarity with fellow Muslims. However, even Arabs want to move on from the endless Israel/Palestine conflict, which has created no winners. While Palestinians have nothing to offer Arab states, Israel (wealthy and economically vibrant) could be a great trade and military partner, as well as a bulwark against the hated Iran. Obviously, the rest of the world would like to move on too from the intractable problem.

   However, for the world to be truly able to move on from the Palestine morass, both Israel and the Palestinian Liberation Organisation need mature, visionary politicians of goodwill who acknowledge that the only long-term solution is the establishment of two states which would fully respect the rights of their own and each other’s citizens, regardless of religion or ethnicity. Unfortunately, neither have politicians of this calibre at the moment. Expect to be writing about the latest iteration of this war in ten years’ time.

   Reply